Invited paper| Volume 21, ISSUE 3, SUPPLEMENT , S32-S36, May 2011

Physicians and Abortion: Provision, Political Participation and Conflicts on the Ground—The Cases of Brazil and Poland



      Two qualitative studies have been conducted between 2002 and 2009 in Poland and Brazil, two different geopolitical settings in which the Catholic Church has had a significant political influence and where abortion is highly restricted. In both countries, struggles for abortion rights have played an important role in challenging the current restrictive policies and bringing attention to the plight of women unable to obtain abortions. This article examines the political role that physicians play in these contestations, drawing on some findings of two larger qualitative studies.


      In Poland semi-structured interviews were conducted with 26 physicians in Warsaw and Krakow and with 55 women aged 18 to 45 in Gdańsk. In Brazil questionnaires were administered and semi-structured interviews conducted with 22 obstetrician-gynecologists and 23 health professionals in two public maternity hospitals in Salvador da Bahia.


      This article argues that gynecologists' perspectives and practices not only reflect or heed religious precepts on reproductive rights, but are also deeply influenced by inadequate medical training and by the fear of being prosecuted or stigmatized, especially in Brazil. The political non-engagement of physicians in Poland is driven by the lack of abortion rights discourse in the public arena, poor links with women's rights groups, and the lack of political unity within the medical community.


      Comparisons between Brazil and Poland ultimately suggest that strong liaisons between physicians and the feminist movement influence physicians' attitudes and political engagement and are most promising in abortion rights advocacy efforts.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'


      Subscribe to Women's Health Issues
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect


        • Barsted L.L.
        O Movimento de mulheres e o debate sobre aborto.
        in: Rocha Baltar da M.I. Barbosa R.M. Aborto no Brasil e países do Cone Sul. NEPO-UNICAMP Ed, Campinas2009: 228-256
      1. Brasil, Ministério da saúde. (1999). Norma Ténica de Prevenção e Tratamento dos Agravos Resultantes da Violência Sexual contra Mulheres e Adolescentes. Brasilia.

        • Cecatti J.G.
        • Souza J.P.
        • Parpinelli M.A.
        • de Sousa M.H.
        • Amaral E.
        Research on severe maternal morbidities and near-misses in Brazil: What we have learned.
        Reproductive Health Matters. 2007; 15: 1-10
      2. Citeli M.T., & Rosado-Nunes M.J. (2009, July 28–31), Controversias sobre o aborto na midia impressa brasileira: Crenças e saberes cientificos e religiosos. Paper presented at XIV Congresso Brasileiro de Sociologia—GT20 Sexualidades, Corporalidades e Transgressoes. Rio de Janeiro.

        • Diniz D.
        • Medeiros M.
        Aborto no Brasil. Uma pesquisa domiciliar com técnica de urna.
        Ciência e Saúde Coletiva. 2010; 15: 959-966
      3. Fuszara, M. (1991). Legal regulation of abortion in Poland. Signs, 117.

        • Gal S.
        • Kligman G.
        The politics of gender after socialism.
        Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ2000
      4. IBGE. (2000). National 2000 census, data on religion—Brazil. Available:

        • Kaiser Family Foundation
        Total fertility rate (Children born per woman) 2009.
        U.S. Global Health Policy. 2009; (Available:) (Accessed December 1, 2010)
        • Maziarski W.
        Terror antyaborcyjny.
        Newsweek Polska. 2008, June 8; 24: 1-2
        • Menezes G.M.S.
        • Aquino E.M.L.
        Mortalidade Materna na Bahia, 1998: Relatório de Pesquisa.
        Instituto de Saúde Coletiva, Secretaria de Saúde do Estado da Bahia, Salvador2001
        • Menezes G.M.S.
        • Aquino E.M.L.
        Pesquisa sobre aborto no Brasil: avanços e desafios para o campo da saúde coletiva.
        Cadernos de saúde pública. 2009; 25: S193-S204
      5. Ministério da Saúde. (2005). Secretaria de Atenção à Saúde, Departamento de Ações Programáticas Estratégicas, Atenção Humanizada ao Abortamento: Norma técnica. Brasília.

        • Mishtal J.
        Matters of conscience: The politics of reproductive health and rights in Poland.
        Medical Anthropology Quarterly. 2009; 23: 173-176
        • Mishtal J.
        How the Church became the state: The Catholic regime and reproductive rights and policies in Poland.
        in: Massino J. Penn S. Women’s lives, gender relations and state policy in Central and Eastern Europe under state socialism. Palgrave MacMillan, New York2009
        • Monteiro M.F.G.
        • Adesse L.
        Estimativas de aborto induzido no Brasil e Grandes Regiões.
        in: Encontro Nacional de Estudos Populacionais, 15, 2006. Anais. Belo Horizonte: ABEP, Caxambu/MG2006
        • Nowakowska U.
        • Korzeniowska M.
        Women’s reproductive rights.
        in: Nowakowska U. Polish women in the 90s (pp, 219–248). Women’s Rights Center, Warsaw2000
      6. Nowicka, W., & Zielinska, A. (2000). Medical community’s perspectives on abortion. Available: Accessed October 8, 2010.

        • Nowicka W.
        Struggles for and against legal abortion in Poland.
        in: Klugman B. Budlender D. Advocating for abortion access: Eleven country studies. The Women’s Health Project, Johannesburg2001: 226-227
      7. Nowicka, W. (2008). The case of a pregnant teen from Lublin: Chronology of events. Available: Accessed October 14, 2010.

        • Pitanguy J.
        O movimento nacional e internacional de saúde e direitos reprodutivos.
        in: Giffin K. Costa S.H. Questões da saúde reprodutiva. FIOCRUZ, Rio de Janeiro1999: 19-38
        • Rocha B.
        • da M.I.
        • Andanalft N.J.A.
        A questão do aborto. Aspectos clínicos, legislativos e politicos.
        in: Berquò E. Sexo e vida. Campinas, Unicamp2003: 257-318
        • Simonetti C.
        • Imais
        Dossiê. A realidade do aborto inseguro na Bahia: a ilegalidade da pratica e seus efeitos na Saúde das Mulheres em Salvador e Feira de Santana.
        IMAIS, Salvador2008, December
        • Tymowska K.
        Health care under transformation in Poland.
        Health Policy. 2001; 56: 85-98
        • Viggiano M.G.C.
        • Souza E. De.
        • Camano L.
        Necessidade de Cuidados Intensivos em Maternidade Pública Terciária.
        Rev Bras Ginecol Obstet. 2004; 26: 317-323
        • World Health Organization
        Highlights on health: Poland: Mortality (p. 1).
        Author, Geneva2005


      Silvia De Zordo, PhD, is a Marie Curie Fellow and a Visiting Researcher at Goldsmiths College, University of London. Her current research examines gynecologists' experiences and attitudes towards abortion and conscientious objection in Italy and in the UK.


      Joanna Mishtal, PhD, is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at the University of Central Florida. Her current research, situated in Ireland and at the European Union, examines the role of conscience-based objection in the provision of reproductive health services.